TWiki> Main Web>TWikiUsers>ChristopheOchando>HiggsMC2012Summary (2012-04-25, NicolasChanon) EditAttachPDF
Contents:

Legend/Infos

  • Bin/Stat "Requested": Initial request
  • Bin/Stat "in PREP": if what is in PREP or submitted was changed wrt to requested...
  • Bin/Stat "Needed": proposal to increase/drop samples/statistics
  • Priority 1 means "Needed for ICHEP"
  • Priority 2 means "Needed after Summer"

Higgs -> gg Group

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
gg->H->2gamma POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00302 -> HIG-Summer12-00323 priority 1: 90, 100,105, 110, 115,120, 123 (500k), 124, 125, 130,135, 140, 145, 150, 155 (100k), priority 2 : 121,126,127, 128 OK OK 1.9M (priority 1), 400k (priority 2) priority 1,2
VBF->H->2gamma POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00636 -> HIG-Summer12-00654 priority 1: 90, 100,105, 110, 115,120, 123 (500k), 124, 125, 130,135, 140, 145, 150, 155 (100k), priority 2 : 121,126,127, 128 OK OK 1.9M (priority 1), 400k (priority 2) priority 1,2
VH->2gamma Pythia6 HIG-Summer12-00093 -> HIG-Summer12-00111 priority 1: 90, 100,105, 110, 115,120, 123 (500k), 124, 125, 130,135, 140, 145, 150, 155 (100k), priority 2 : 121,126,127, 128 OK OK 1.9M (priority 1), 400k (priority 2) priority 1,2
ttH->2gamma Pythia6 HIG-Summer12-00112 -> HIG-Summer12-00130 priority 1: 90, 100,105, 110, 115,120, 123 (500k), 124, 125, 130,135, 140, 145, 150, 155 (100k), priority 2 : 121,126,127, 128 OK OK 1.9M (priority 1), 400k (priority 2) priority 1,2
gg->H->Zgamma POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00293 -> HIG-Summer12-00301 120,125,130,135,140,145,150,155,160 (100k) OK OK 900k priority 1
VBF->H->Zgamma POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00775 -> HIG-Summer12-00783 120,125,130,135,140,145,150,155,160 (100k) OK OK 900k priority 1
VH->Zgamma Pythia6 HIG-Summer12-00590 -> HIG-Summer12-00598 120,125,130,135,140,145,150,155,160 (1M) 9x1M 9x100k new : 900k priority 1
ttH->Zgamma Pythia6 HIG-Summer12-00393 -> HIG-Summer12-00402 120,125,130,135,140,145,150,155,160 (100k) OK OK 900k priority 1
TOTAL Priority 1         11.2M
gg->H->2gamma Pythia HIG-Summer12-00386, HIG-Summer12-00388, HIG-Summer12-00389 120, 125, 130 (100k) 300k OK 300k priority 2
VBF H->2gamma Pythia HIG-Summer12-00352, HIG-Summer12-00366, HIG-Summer12-00368 120, 125, 130 (100k) 300k OK 300k priority 2
gg->H->2gamma Madgraph   120,125,130 (200k) TO BE ENTERED   300k priority 2

General comment
 

Higgs -> ZZ Group

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
gg->H->ZZ->4l (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00328->HIG-Summer12-00385 115, 116, 117, 118, 119 (300k), 120 (1M), 121, 122, 123, 124 (300k), 125 (1M), 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 135, 140, 145 (300k), 150 (1M), 160, 170, 180, 190 (300k), 200 (1M), 210, 220, 230, 250, 275, 300, 325, 350, 375, 400, 425, 450, 475, 500, 525, 550, 575, 600, 650, 700, 750, 800, 850, 900, 950, 1000 (300K), 4x1M, 47*300k OK Drop 116, 118, 122, 128, 129, 135, 140, 145, 160, 170, 190, 210, 230, 275, 375, 425, 475, 525, 575 (19*300k) 18 M (initial), 12M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
VBF H->ZZ->4l (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00724->HIG-Summer12-00774 same binning (51x50K) OK drop 19x50k 2.5 M (initial), 1.5 M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
             
gg->H->ZZ->2L2Q (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00453 -> HIG-Summer12-00488 120, 125, 130, 140, 150, 160, 170, 180, 190, 200, 210, 220, 230, 250, 275, 300, 325, 350, 375, 400, 425, 450, 475, 500, 525, 550, 575, 600, 650, 700, 750, 800, 850, 900, 950, 1000 (36x300K) OK Drop 140, 160, 170, 190, 210, 230, 275, 375, 425, 475, 525, 575 (12*300k) 10.8M (Initial), 7.2 M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
VBF H->ZZ->2L2Q (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00655->HIG-Summer12-00690 same binning (36x50k) OK drop 12x50k 1.8M (initial), 1.2 M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
             
gg->H->ZZ->2L2Nu (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00534 -> HIG-Summer12-00566 120, 130, 140, 150, 160, 170, 180, 190, 200, 225, 250, 275, 300, 325, 350, 375, 400, 425, 450, 475, 500, 525, 550, 575, 600, 650, 700, 750, 800, 850, 900, 950, 1000 (33x300K) ok Drop 130, 140, 160, 170, 190, 275, 375, 425, 475, 525, 575 (11x300k) 9.9M (initial), 6.6 M (initial) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
VBF H->ZZ->2L2Nu (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00691->HIG-Summer12-00723 same binning (33*50k) ok drop 11x50k 1.65 M (initial), 1.1 M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped)
             
WH/ZH/ttH, H->ZZ (Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00185-> HIG-Summer12-00215 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 160, 170, 180, 190, 200, 210, 220, 230, 250, 275, 300 (31x500k) OK Drop all 15.5M (initial), 0 (reduced) priority 2 for dropped
             
Higgs ZZ->4l, 0+ (JHU+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00161->HIG-Summer12-00168 110, 120, 125, 130, 140, 250, 500, 1000 (8x200k)   Drop 110, 130, 140, 250, 1000 (5x200k) 1.6M (initial), 1M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped). LHE in validation
Higgs ZZ->4l, 0- (JHU+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00169->HIG-Summer12-00177 110, 120, 125, 130, 140, 250, 500, 1000 (8x200k)   Drop 110, 130, 140, 250, 1000 (5x200k) 1.6M (initial), 1M (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped). LHE in validation
Higgs ZZ->2l2j, 0+ (JHU+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00178->HIG-Summer12-00180 250, 500, 1000 (3x200k)   Drop 250, 1000 600k(Initial), 200k (reduced) Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped). LHE in validation
Higgs ZZ->2l2j, 0- (JHU+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00181->HIG-Summer12-00183 250, 500, 1000 (3x200k)   600k(Initial), 200k (reduced)   Priority 1 (priority 2 for dropped). LHE in validation
Higgs ZZ->2l2nu, 0+ (JHU+Pythia6) TBC (?x200k)   Drop ?   No LHE. Is it possible with JHU ???
Higgs ZZ->2l2nu, 0- (JHU+Pythia6) TBC (?x200k)   Drop ?   No LHE. Is it possible with JHU ???
             
2HDM H->ZA->2l2tau            
Z -> ZH -> ll+MET            
H->aa->2mu2tau            
TOTAL Priority 1         32M

General comment
 

Higgs -> WW Group

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
gg->H->WW->2L2Nu (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00238->HIG-Summer12-00264 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155, 160, 170, 180, 190, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500, 550, 600, 700, 800, 900, 1000 (28x300K) OK OK 8M priority 1
gg->H->WW->2L2Nu (MC@NLO) not yet same binning, same stats ? not yet not yet ? priority 2
VBF H->WW->2l2Nu (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00433->HIG-Summer12-00608 same binning, 28x300k OK OK 8M priority 1
ttH/WH/ZH, H->WW (Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00065->HIG-Summer12-00081 110->300 (17x200k) OK OK 3.4 M Priority 1
gg->H->WW->lnujj (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00265->HIG-Summer12-00281 160, 170, 180, 190, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500, 550, 600, 700, 800, 900, 1000 (17x200K) OK Drop 160, 170, 180, 190, 250, 350, 450, 550, 700, 800, 900, 1000 3.4M (Intial) 1M (Reduced) Priority 1, Priority 2 for Dropped
VBF H->WW->lnujj (POWHEG+Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00451->HIG-Summer12-00635 same binning (17x200K) OK Drop 160, 170, 180, 190, 250, 350, 450, 550, 700, 800, 900, 1000 3.4M (Initial) 1M (Reduced) Priority 1, Priority 2 for Dropped
WH (H->WW) -> 3l (Pythia) HIG-Summer12-00407->HIG-Summer12-00417 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155, 160 (11x100k) OK Drop 110, 115, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155 (7x100k) 1.1M (Intial), 400k (reduced) Priority 1, Priority 2 for Dropped
TOTAL Priority 1         21.8M

Higgs -> TauTau Group

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
gg->H->tautau POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00282 -> HIG-Summer12-00292 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155, 160 (1M) 5M+10x1M OK 15M priority 1
VBF H->tautau POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00609 -> HIG-Summer12-00619 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155, 160 (1M) 5M+10x1M OK 15M priority 1
VH, ttH, H->tautau POWHEG HIG-Summer12-00082 -> HIG-Summer12-00092 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135, 140, 145, 150, 155, 160 (200k) 11x200k OK 2.2M priority 1
SUSY bbH, H->tautau HIG-Summer12-00044 -> HIG-Summer12-00064 80,90,100,110,120,130,140,160,180,200,250,300,350,400,450,500,600,700,800,900,1000 (1M) 21x1M 21x200k 4.2M (21M) priority 1 (ask to re-increase ?)
SUSY ggH, H->tautau HIG-Summer12-00023 -> HIG-Summer12-00043 80,90,100,110,120,130,140,160,180,200,250,300,350,400,450,500,600,700,800,900,1000 (1M) 21x1M 21x200k 4.2M (21M) priority 1 (ask to re-increase ?)
TOTAL Priority 1         40.6M (74.2M asked)
gg->H->tautau Pythia HIG-Summer12-00387 -> HIG-Summer12-00392 100, 120, 140, 160 (1M) 4M OK 4M priority 2
VBF H->tautau Pythia HIG-Summer12-00369 -> HIG-Summer12-00377 100, 120, 140, 160 (1M) 4M OK 4M priority 2
tt->H+bWb HIG-Summer12-00216 -> HIG-Summer12-00230 80,90,100,120,140,150,155,160 (200k) 8M OK 1.6M priority 2
tt->H+bH-b HIG-Summer12-00224 -> HIG-Summer12-00230 80,90,100,120,140,150,155,160 (200k) 8M OK 1.6M priority 2
gg/qq->tbH+ HIG-Summer12-00232 -> HIG-Summer12-00237 180,190,200,220,250,300 (200k) 1.2M OK 1.2M priority 2
gg->H->tautau Madgraph   100, 120, 140, 160 (1M) TO BE ENTERED   4M priority 2

Higgs -> bb Group

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
ZH,Z->ll, H->bb (POWHEG+Herwig++) HIG-Summer12-00131->HIG-Summer12-00136 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135 (1M) 6*200k ? 6*1M? 1.2M (6M?) priority 1
ZH, Z-> nunu, H->bb (POWHEG+Herwig++) HIG-Summer12-00137->HIG-Summer12-00142 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135 (1M) 6*200k ? 6*1M? 1.2M (6M?) priority 1
WH, W-> lnu, H->bb (POWHEG+Herwig++) HIG-Summer12-00143->HIG-Summer12-00148 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135 (1M) 6*200k ? 6*1M? 1.2M (6M?) priority 1
ZH, Z->bb, H->bb (POWHEG+Herwig++) HIG-Summer12-00509 -> HIG-Summer12-00514 110, 115, 120, 125, 130, 135 (1M) ? ? 6M priority 1
ZH, WH, H->bb (MC@NLO) not yet 6x3x1M ? not yet not yet not yet priority 2 ? Need LHE...
VBF, H->bb (Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00503 120 (100k) ? ? 100k ?
SUSY gg->bH, H->bb (Pythia) HIG-Summer12-00515 -> HIG-Summer12-00533 90, 100, 120, 130 (1M), 140, 160, 180, 200, 250, 300, 350 (500k), 400, 450, 500, 600, 700, 800, 900, 1000 (250k) to be checked ? 10M priority 2 ? TO BE CHECKED
SM/pp->bH-> bbb (Pythia6) HIG-Summer12-00489 -> HIG-Summer12-00493 90, 120 (1M), 150, 180, 210 (500k) ? ? ? priority 2 ? TO BE CHECKED
ttH, H->bb (Pythia) HIG-Summer12-00584 -> HIG-Summer12-00589 110->135 (6x1M) ok ok 6M priority 1. TO BE CHECKED
ttH, H->bb (Madgraph) ? ? ? ? ? priority 2 ? TO BE CHECKED
SUSY, bbH, H->bb, Mu Enriched HIG-Summer12-00573 120 (200k) ok ok 200k priority 1
SUSY, bbH, H->bb, Mu Enriched HIG-Summer12-00573 90,100,120,130 (1M),140,160, 180,200,250,300,350 (500k), 400,450,500,600,700,800,900,1000 (250k) ok ok 9.5M priority 1
TOTAL Priority 1         19.3M (33.7M asked)

Backgrounds

Sample / Generator PREP Id Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Binning & Statistics Total Comment
    Requested in PREP Needed    
Diphoton Born Pythia HIG-Summer12-00014, HIG-Summer12-00015, HIG-Summer12-00324 3 pthat bins (500k) OK OK 1.5M priority 1, H->GG and SMP
Diphoton Box Pythia HIG-Summer12-00325 -> HIG-Summer12-00327 3 pthat bins (500k) OK OK 1.5M priority 1, H->GG and SMP
Diphoton+Jets Madgraph QCD-Summer12-00007, HIG-Summer12-00418 2 Mgg bins (1M) OK OK 2M priority 1, H->GG and SMP
Gamma+Jet doubleEM Pythia HIG-Summer12-00569 -> HIG-Summer12-00570 2 pthat bins (6M) 2x6M OK new : 6+12M (ICHEP), 12M more later priority 1, H->GG
QCD doubleEM Pythia HIG-Summer12-00567 -> HIG-Summer12-00568 2 pthat bins (6+50M) 6+10M 6+10(ICHEP)+40(later) 16M (56M) priority 1, H->GG
             
W+jets (inclusive, Madgraph) EWK-Summer12-00064 100M ~20M ? 20M priority 1, Needed by HWW, Htautau, Hbb
W+ 1 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00006 31 M ? ? 31M priority 2 Needed by HWW
W+ 2 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00007 34 M ? ? 34M priority 2 Needed by HWW
W+ 3 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00008 16 M ? ? 16M priority 2 Needed by HWW
W+ 4 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00009 13 M ? ? 13M priority 2 Needed by HWW
             
DY+jets (inclusive, Madgraph), mll>50 GeV EWK-Summer12-00063 54M ~14M ? 14M priority 1, Needed by HWW, Htautau, HZZ, Hbb, Hgg
DY+ 1 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00002 24M ? ? 24M? priority 1. Needed by HZZ
DY+ 2 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00003 22M ? ? 22M? priority 1. Needed by HZZ
DY+ 3 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00004 10M ? ? 10M? priority 1. Needed by HZZ
DY+ 4 j (exclusive) EWK-Summer12-00062 6.3M ? ? 6.3M ? priority 1. Needed by HZZ
DY+jets (inclusive, Madgraph), 10<mll<50 GeV HIG-Summer12-00001 39 M 10M ? ? 10 M ? priority 1, Needed by HZZ, ?
DY+ 1 j (exclusive), 10<mll<50 GeV HIG-Summer12-00002 8 M ? ? 8 M priority 1 Needed by HZZ.
DY+ 2 j (exclusive), 10<mll<50 GeV TBC ? ? ? ? priority 1 LHE in progress
DY+ 3 j (exclusive), 10<mll<50 GeV TBC ? ? ? ? priority 1 LHE in progress
DY+ 4 j (exclusive), 10<mll<50 GeV TBC ? ? ? ? priority 1 LHE in progress
DY+jets (inclusive, Madgraph), 10GeV, FILTERED HIG-Summer12-00431 600M (LHE), ~10 M ? (matching+reco) ? 10M ? 10M ? priority 1, Needed by HWW, HZZ. Filter: >=2 e/mu, pt>7, eta<3. Potential problem with existing LHE
             
Zbb, mll>50 (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00425 5M ?     5M ? priority 1. Needed by HZZ. Problem with LHE
Zbb, 10<mll<50 (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00426 2.5M ?     2.5M ? priority 1. Needed by HZZ. Problem with LHE
Zcc, mll>50 (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00427 5M ?     5M ? priority 1. Needed by HZZ. Problem with LHE
Zcc, 10<mll<50 (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00428 2.5M ?     2.5M ? priority 1. Needed by HZZ. Problem with LHE
             
DY, mll>20 (POWHEG+Pythia6) EWK-Summer12-00076, EWK-Summer12-00077, EWK-Summer12-00082 ee, mumu, tautau (3x50M, LHE) 3x3M More ? 9M? more ? Priority 1. Needed by HWW
DY, 10<mll<20 (POWHEG+Pythia6) EWK-Summer12-00079, EWK-Summer12-00083, EWK-Summer12-00084 ee, mumu, tautau (3x170M, LHE) 3x10 M More ? 10M ? more ? Priority 1. Needed by ?
DY, 10<mll<20 (POWHEG+Pythia6) FILTERED EWK-Summer12-00078, EWK-Summer12-00080 ee, mumu, tautau (170Mx3 at LHE) ~12 M More ?! 12M Priority 1. Needed by HWW
             
Boosted Z->nunu+jets (Madgraph) TBC ZpT>100, ~15M tbd ok 15M Priority 1. Needed by Hbb
Boosted DY->ll +jets (Madgraph) TBC ZpT: 50-70, 70-100,>100 (3+3.7+7) ok ok 14M Priorty 1. Needed by Hbb
Boosted W->lnu+jets (Madgraph) TBC WpT: 50-70, 70-100,>100 (14+23+53) ok Drop 50-70 (53M) Initial (90M), reduced (37M) Priorty 1, Priority 2 for dropped. Needed by Hbb
Boosted W/Z (Herwig++) TBC ~30M tbd Drop ? Initial (30M), Reduced (0) Priority 2. Needed by Hbb
             
Di-top (inclusive, Madgraph) TBC 80 M 6M ? 6M ? more ? Priority 1. Needed by ?
Di-top -> dilepton (POWHEG) TBC 10 M ? ? 10M ? Priority 1. Needed by HWW, HZZ. LHE need to be produced
Single Top (POWHEG) TOP-Summer12-00006->TOP-Summer12-00011 100k+2M+800k+800k+300k+14k 4M ? 4M Priority 1. Needed by HWW, Htautau, ?
             
Pythia WZ inclusive   10M OK OK 10M priority 1, H->GG, H->WW
Pythia ZZ inclusive   10M OK OK 10M priority 1, H->GG, H->ZZ
ZZ (inclusive, Pythia) HIG-Summer12-00007 10M ok ok 10M Priority 1. Needed by Hgg
WW->2l2nu (Madgraph HIG-Summer12-00419 2M ok ok 2M Priority 1. Needed by HWW
ZZ->leptons/jets (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00420->HIG-Summer12-00422 4l, 2l2j, 2l2nu (5+1+2M) ok ok 8M Priority 1. Needed by HWW, HZZ.
ZZ->other decays (Madgraph) TBC (?) tbd tbd ? Priority ? Needed by Hbb. People working on LHE
WZ->leptons/jets (Madgraph) HIG-Summer12-00423, HIG-Summer12-00424 3l1nu, 2l2j (3M+3M) tbd tbd 6M? Priority 1. Needed by HWW, HZZ, HTauTau. Problem with LHE
WZ->other decays (Madgraph) TBC ? tbd tbd ? Priority ? Needed by Hbb. People working on LHE
WW->2l2nu (MC@NLO) HIG-Summer12-00149->HIG-Summer12-00151 nominal, scale up/down (500kx3)     1.5 M Priority 1. Needed by HWW. Need the LHE
ZZ->4l, mll>4 (POWHEG TBC 4e,4mu,2e2mu,4tau,2e2tau,2mu2tau (6x1.5M) ok decrease taus statistics 9M (initial), 6.75M (reduced) Priority 1. Needed by HZZ
gg->ZZ->4l (gg2zz) TBC 4l, 2l2l' (2x500k) ok ok 1M Priority 1. Needed by HZZ. Need the LHE
gg->WW->4l (gg2ww) TBC 2l2nu (500k) ok ok 500k Priority 1. Needed by HWW. Need the LHE
             
W+gamma TBC 10 M ?     10M ? Priority 1. Needed by HWW, Hgg. Problem with the LHE
Z+gamma TBC 10 M ?     10M ? Priority 1. Needed by HWW, Hgg. Problem with the LHE
W+gamma* TBC 10 M ?     10M ? Priority 1. Needed by HWW. On-going work for the LHE
             
Madgraph Zgammagamma   ? TO BE ENTERED ? ? priority 2, H->GG
Madgraph Wgammagamma   ? TO BE ENTERED ? ? priority 2, H->GG
Madgraph TTgammagamma   ? TO BE ENTERED ? ? priority 2, H->GG
TOTAL Priority 1         383M

-- ChristopheOchando - 27-Mar-2012

Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r12 < r11 < r10 < r9 < r8 | Backlinks | Raw View | WYSIWYG | More topic actions
Topic revision: r12 - 2012-04-25 - NicolasChanon
 
    • Cern Search Icon Cern Search
    • TWiki Search Icon TWiki Search
    • Google Search Icon Google Search

    Main All webs login

This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright &© 2008-2024 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
or Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? use Discourse or Send feedback